Skip to main content

A musical metaphor I hope to explore

A long HN Comment that says, in part:

An analogy about the relationship between programs and languages just occurred to me, which I want to note so I don't forget it: it's like the relationship between a piece of music and the instrument it was composed for. To say "this system could have been built in some other language" is like saying "this music could have been composed for another instrument". That may technically be true; music gets transcribed for other instruments all the time, just as programs get ported to other languages. But this misses the most important thing: the creative process by which the music or program got written in the first place.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Accounts

You can set up a new account to save your wardrobe but can't order anything until you get measured. Setting up a new account will prompt you to make an appointment with the nearest certified seamstress allowed to measure you. This potentially tells us where to go certify a bunch of new people. If enough people create an account in x city, we make sure to arrange a certified seamstress as soon as possible if there isn't one yet.
Post a Comment
Read more

The Norway Problem

The Norway Problem - why StrictYAML refuses to do implicit typing and so should you Norway abbreviates as NO. This is a real word and some programs will alter that to a programming command, such as "False." A workaround in some cases is to put it in quotation marks, but you may not know that ahead of time. There are other cases like this, such as a person whose last name is Null . Found via HN . Related reading: Principle of least astonishment A textbook formulation is: "People are part of the system. The design should match the user's experience, expectations, and mental models."
Post a Comment
Read more